<body><script type="text/javascript"> function setAttributeOnload(object, attribute, val) { if(window.addEventListener) { window.addEventListener('load', function(){ object[attribute] = val; }, false); } else { window.attachEvent('onload', function(){ object[attribute] = val; }); } } </script> <div id="navbar-iframe-container"></div> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://apis.google.com/js/plusone.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript"> gapi.load("gapi.iframes:gapi.iframes.style.bubble", function() { if (gapi.iframes && gapi.iframes.getContext) { gapi.iframes.getContext().openChild({ url: 'https://draft.blogger.com/navbar.g?targetBlogID\x3d8138691\x26blogName\x3dThe+Duck+Mafia\x26publishMode\x3dPUBLISH_MODE_BLOGSPOT\x26navbarType\x3dBLACK\x26layoutType\x3dCLASSIC\x26searchRoot\x3dhttp://duckmafia.blogspot.com/search\x26blogLocale\x3den_GB\x26v\x3d2\x26homepageUrl\x3dhttp://duckmafia.blogspot.com/\x26vt\x3d-4737369332786410374', where: document.getElementById("navbar-iframe-container"), id: "navbar-iframe" }); } }); </script>

April 05, 2005

Sin City

2005.USA.Rodriguez

2.5 / 4.0

Robert Rodriguez’s adaptation of Frank Miller’s series of Sin City graphic novels is the latest link in an already hefty chain of films that try to overcome a lack of substance with an abundance of style. Although substantially better than Kerry Conran’s awful Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow (USA), and international empty but pretty pictures Casshern (Japan) and Immortel (France), Sin City still suffers from fundamental structural problems that no amount of technical excellence or special effects can overcome. It lacks a clear plot, is inhabited by too many characters (for someone other than Robert Altman to contend with), and relies on an irritating amount of narration. Furthermore, the acting varies from excellent (Benicio Del Toro as “Jackie Boy”) through mediocre (Bruce Willis as the stone faced “Hartigan") to embarrassingly bad (Jessica Alba as “Nancy"), and the directing, though adequate, is too concerned with recreating comic book frames than adding to them.

Filmmakers should know that what works in one medium rarely works in another. It’s the reason that many film adaptations of Shakespeare fail to work convincingly on the silver screen, or that many faithful adaptations of popular novels don’t have nearly the same power as the original works. Judging from his El Mariachi days, Robert Rodriguez should know, for example, that films are best when they rely on action and visual exposition over narration and dialogue. In his excellent book “The Technique of Screenplay Writing”, Eugene Vale makes the distinction that film, a medium physically based on motion and progression, should exploit exactly these qualities. He compares the same scene, of a warrior in battle dress, as done in a painting and literature, and points out that a painting shows all of its information at once while a story is better suited to reveal information progressively. According to Vale, a film, like literature, should show its warrior actually fasten the leather straps of his boots, throw his heavy shield over his shoulder and clutch his spear rather than simply the resulting image. In other words, good films make visual the process. In Sin City, Rodriguez resorts too often to narration by his three main characters (Hartigan, Marv and Dwight) in order to give their histories, tell their thoughts, or soften and explain the jump cuts that he uses repeatedly. Although this is done to simulate the reading of a comic, which is made of several hundred frames and cannot convey everything through images, it is not suitable for a film like Sin City, which contains roughly 180,000 frames. The argument could be made that Rodriguez simply doesn’t have enough space, or time, to show everything, but that itself shows flaws in the film’s structure. And, there are also copious action and driving scenes that drag on for far too long and that cannot be justified only because they were in the original material.

In the early days of cinema, a filmed theatre play, or “canned theatre”, was a popular and quick way to bring theatre to a wider audience and one outside of large urban centres. In these productions, the camera would simulate the eyes of a spectator sitting in an expensive seat in the front row of an actual theatre. The result was not cinema as much as a poor, flat replica of a stage production minus the plasticity, unpredictability and immediacy of the actual play. Although Rodriguez’s film is much more than a camera recording of an invisible hand flipping the pages of one of the Frank Miller’s graphic novels, it is perhaps not too much of an overstatement to call it “canned comics”. Like “canned theatre”, Sin City takes many of the elements that work in the form of a comic, and mimics them on celluloid. The Sin City website even has a section that compares frames from the comic with those from the film, as if a perfect similarity was somehow equal to a perfect film. If that was true, a perfect film adaptation of Picasso’s Guernica could be created with a two-hour still frame that uncannily resembled the massive painting.

Another problem that Rodriguez created for himself upon conceiving the idea of a Sin City film was the notion that he could cram a handful of graphic novels, each with its own plot and characters, into a motion picture running slightly more than two hours. For an entirely unfair comparison, imagine some ambitious writer and director taking upon himself the monumental task of creating a film adapted from several Dickens novels, simply because they take place in the same city and period. Is it madness, or is it possible? On the basis of Sin City, it’s the former. History, Eugene Vale and Aristotle suggest that one dramatic work should have one main plot, from which everything else stems and which propels the story. On the other hand, experience shows that this is not always the case, and films have been made that fly in the face of conventional ideas about structure. Regardless, the problem with Sin City is that it doesn’t work and it doesn’t work because it has a weak plot structure and weak characters. Constructed like four consecutive episodes of a television show (though David Lynch managed to make a whole out of some spare TV parts with Mulholland Drive), none of the characters are truly developed and no one plotline strong enough to carry the film. Characters and plots disappear, appear, but never connect in any meaningful way. Attempts are made at thematic unity through motifs (Men defending women, betrayal, corruption, etc.) and the repetition of certain lines of dialogue, but it’s superficial and forced. The main unifying factor, as can be deemed from the title, is The City, but that, like the film, has a style but no heart or soul. Near the end, Rodriguez even resorts to showing various characters from the three main stories together in a bar in a feeble attempt at tying things together. But string don’t hold elephants. Not surprisingly, the film has an incredibly weak ending.

Overall, Sin City is still an enjoyable film. Its ability to recognize and employ the sarcasm that pervades classic Noir and to recreate its mood while balanced between pastiche and homage are high points, for example. As are the technical aspects, and the fact that the film was made outside of the regular Hollywood loop, on video and without actual sets. But it’s impossible to overlook the shortcomings of the narrative. Perhaps if Miller and Rodriguez had hired a screenwriter to write the film, or focused on just one of Miller’s graphic novels, Sin City would have been a better motion picture. And maybe if Rodriguez wasn’t so intent on being faithful to the source material, he would have made a better film. As it stands, whatever Sin City is to fans of Miller and comic books in general, it is not revolutionary cinema, as some have made it out to be. If anything, the film’s “canned comic” brand of adaptation is a step backward. In order to make great films, one must understand the film medium and its strengths, weaknesses and peculiarities. Knowledge of comic books not required.

16 Comments:

Blogger Chase McInerney said...

A great assessment ... interesting how my take on "Sin City" is almost identical to yours. Anyway, great post (and not just 'cause I agree).

6:32 pm  
Blogger jon said...

We are trying to find good scary movie to take the kids this weekend. Good scary movie reviews are hard to find

I just stumbled onto your blog while looking. Seems to happen to me a lot since I am a knowledge mooch LOL

Thanks

5:21 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I have a buy book site. It pretty much covers buy book related stuff. Check it out if you get time :-)

11:45 am  
Blogger Admin said...

Wow, what a great site. I will bookmark this site and return often. It's nice to see sites like this.

Please visit my website and let me know what you think. Secret Confession

1:59 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Nice Blog

Best Wishes

I have a site 80 million Down Loadable Movies If you have the time stop by.

4:14 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

You may want to check this site out you will Save a bundle


Misspelledauctions.com

11:36 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Bizarre Secret Confesson Warning, these cofessions will shock you. Very disturbing Stuff. If you have something on your heart or something weighing on your soul then I saw this site and you should go over there anc confess. No one has to know it is you. It is private. I at your secret confession and I really felt a lot better afterward. You can confess ALL at http://www.yoursecretconfession.com/forum

1:50 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hey there, you've got a great blog here!
Did it take you long to set up?
It's taken me quite a few weeks,
The first two templates I didn't like
And now if someone has a long heading
It pushes the main articles way down the page.
It's kind of anoying when that happens.
I have a avia guide to home theater site.
It pretty much covers pocketbike related stuff.
Come and check it out if you get time :-)

11:07 pm  
Blogger sdRay said...

My name is Ray and I just started a new blog about the confession music. Its a place where you can chat about the confession music confidentially. I hope you will come and check out www.MySecretConfessionSpace.com. Thanks for letting me post on your site.

4:48 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

equity credit line
credit equity home information line
credit equity home line loan low mortgage rate
credit equity home home line loan low mortgage rate
credit does equity home line work
credit equity home illinois line
credit equity florida home line
100 credit equity home line
bad credit equity home line loan low mortgage rate
bank credit equity home line ohio savings
credit equity home line michigan
credit equity home line tax
125 credit equity home line
credit equity home interest line rate
credit equity home line refinance
citibank credit equity home line
bad credit equity line
credit equity home line question
credit equity line loan
credit equity fargo home line well
best credit equity home line
credit equity home line texas
california credit equity home line
bankruptcy credit equity home line
credit equity home line virginia
credit equity equity home home line loan vs
credit equity home line mutual washington
bad credit credit equity home line
conventional credit equity home line loan other vs
calculator credit equity line
credit equity fixed home line rate
credit equity home line loan versus
best credit equity home line rate
credit equity home line mobile
credit equity home line loan vs
calculator credit equity home line
credit equity line rate
credit equity home line loan
credit equity home line rate
credit equity line
credit equity home line
equity credit lines
Equity Line of Credit

12:11 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

MESSAGE

11:34 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

equity credit line
credit equity home information line
credit equity home line loan low mortgage rate
credit equity home home line loan low mortgage rate
credit does equity home line work
credit equity home illinois line
credit equity florida home line
100 credit equity home line
bad credit equity home line loan low mortgage rate
bank credit equity home line ohio savings
credit equity home line michigan
credit equity home line tax
125 credit equity home line
credit equity home interest line rate
credit equity home line refinance
citibank credit equity home line
bad credit equity line
credit equity home line question
credit equity line loan
credit equity fargo home line well
best credit equity home line
credit equity home line texas
california credit equity home line
bankruptcy credit equity home line
credit equity home line virginia
credit equity equity home home line loan vs
credit equity home line mutual washington
bad credit credit equity home line
conventional credit equity home line loan other vs
calculator credit equity line
credit equity fixed home line rate
credit equity home line loan versus
best credit equity home line rate
credit equity home line mobile
credit equity home line loan vs
calculator credit equity home line
credit equity line rate
credit equity home line loan
credit equity home line rate
credit equity line
credit equity home line
equity credit lines
Equity Line of Credit

11:34 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

MESSAGE

2:59 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hello
cialis vs viagra
cialis levitra viagra vs vs
cialis drug viagra vs
cialis levitra viagra vs
cialis strong viagra vs
cialis levitra search viagra vs
cialis search viagra vs
cialis effects side viagra vs
cialis levitra search viagra vs vs
viagra vs cialis
Bye

2:59 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

MESSAGE

6:46 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

http://invest-options-online.usabestlink.info - invest options online

http://option-investing.usabestlink.info - option investing

[URL=http://invest-options-online.usabestlink.info/index.html]invest options online[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/index.html]option investing[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/investing-in-future-and-option-market.html]investing in future and option market[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/lease-option-investing.html]lease option investing[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/fear-investing-option-without.html]fear investing option without[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/investing-lease-option-turnkey.html]investing lease option turnkey[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/lease-option-real-estate-investing.html]lease option real estate investing[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/investing-in-option.html]investing in option[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/investing-in-stock-option.html]investing in stock option[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/stock-option-investing.html]stock option investing[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/future-in-investing-market-option.html]future in investing market option[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/investing-lease-option.html]investing lease option[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/fear-investing-option-without.html]fear investing option without[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/investing-lease-option-turnkey.html]investing lease option turnkey[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/estate-investing-lease-option-real.html]estate investing lease option real[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/in-investing-option.html]in investing option[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/investing-option.html]investing option[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/in-investing-option-stock.html]in investing option stock[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/investing-option-stock.html]investing option stock[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/investing-in-future-and-option-market.html]investing in future and option market[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/lease-option-investing.html]lease option investing[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/fear-investing-option-without.html]fear investing option without[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/investing-lease-option-turnkey.html]investing lease option turnkey[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/lease-option-real-estate-investing.html]lease option real estate investing[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/investing-in-option.html]investing in option[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/investing-in-stock-option.html]investing in stock option[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/stock-option-investing.html]stock option investing[/URL]
[URL=http://option-investing.usabestlink.info/invest-options-online.html]invest options online[/URL]

6:46 am  

Post a Comment

<< Home